Friday, July 12, 2024

Ludwig Baer...buy his book

 As I've stated many times before, this blog focuses on the beginning and novice (like me) helmet collector.  Here is some valuable advice for you

Our hobby suffers a plague of highly-priced fakes and tampered-with helmets.  This is no more true than in the category of German helmets of the Third Reich.  It is a minefield for beginning and experienced collector alike.  The problem is of such magnitude that one is justified to believe that any German helmet is fake until proven otherwise.  That sounds extreme, but even some of the leading "experts" in the field have been duped by unscrupulous dealers, and more tragically, some of those trusted experts have been knowlingly dealing in fakes themselves.

That preamble leads to this:  if you are embarking on a collection that includes TR (Third Reich) helmets, proceed with great caution, the risks and the potential for financial loss are high, not to mention the regret and embarrassment you will have when holding that $2,000 fake in your hands.

Seasoned collectors have a mantra for novice collectors of TR helmets - educate yourself.  Now many of them will simply say "buy books", that may have been good advice at one time, but these days many of those lavish, large-format books with page after page of beautiful helmet photographs, are little more than helmet pornography - very little information and beautiful pictures of helmets, many of which are fake.  This leads us to ask "Whom can I trust?"  

For me, the simplest way to have confidence is to go to the back of the book and look for a bibliography and cited sources, that is the mark of a scholar and a true expert in the field, and sadly these books are very difficult to find.  Less than a third of the books on my helmet bookshelf are authored by these scholar-collectors, and that seems to be the standard today.  The self-appointed experts do not attend to the basic standards of research that any highschool freshman is accountable for using.

That leads me to the book The History of the German Steel Helmet: 1916 - 1945, published in 1985, by Ludwig Baer.

Baer has been established as the leading authority on the subject, he is totally legit and a wealth of good information.  His analysis is sound and based upon exhaustive research of primary documents - something you seldom find in other helmet books (excluding the excellent work of Mark Reynosa and others).

This book has been out of print for many years, and I have seen copies of it selling for up to two-hundred dollars.  This may seem like a lot of money, but it pales in comparison to the loss you will take by buying a very convincing fake of a TR helmet.  I cannot overstate the essential value of this book.  If you want to enter the risky area of TR collecting, you simply must get this book and do the research.

Buy it.

See you next time with another cool helmet from the collection.

Mannie


Tuesday, July 9, 2024

France, m.78 f1 combat helmet

In the post- WWII era, France adopted several helmets, none of which were found to be suitable to the French. They used cast-off M1s from the United States, the odd m. 41 Jeanne d' Arc (DeGualle) helmet, and the gererally unpopular m.51  which was merely a French re-design of the two-piece M1.


The utterly unique, and decidedly odd-looking, m.41


The clumsy, ill-fitting, and unatractive m.51

France was looking for a distinctly French helmet, which was wonderfully achieved in the m.78 f1.

One of the last, if not the last, steel helmets designed, and manufactured, was the French m.78 f1 helmet.  This helmet served France until the very early 1980s to the very early 2000s; and is, in my opinion, one of the most attractive and well designed helmets ever.




I find the shape of this helmet similar to many of the Eastern block countries of the Cold War era, especially the Soviet m.40 - the lines are very similar. Sorry for the soft-focus - I think I had the camera in "Joan Crawford-mode."



The camouflge is the CE (central Europe) version of the US woodland pattern, The colors are nearly the same, but the color blocks are considerably larger than the traditional woodland pattern.



Securing the cover to the shell, and integral to the camouflage cover, is a rubber bumper circling the entire lower edge of the helmet.  

Here's a tip, if you acquire this helmet, think twice about removing this cover as it comes off fairly easily, but is an absolute bear to get back on.



The cover is comprised of a rubber ring and four panels meeting at the dome.


The liner may be one of the most efficient, well-designed, and comfortable of any 20th century helmet.


The straps are synthetic. and the snaps that secure both ends of the chinstraps are very robust.  The double set of snaps allows adjustment for the use of a Gasmask.  The snaps also provide quick, and spontaneous, release when nearby explosions happen; the quick release, under -pressure, helps to prevent neck-injuries in those instances.


The comfortable, and well-fitting chincup is a combination of leather, synthetic leather, and plastic.  It also has well-placed ventilation holes.  Good ventilation and comfort are hallmarks of this helmet.


This example is the earlier of two versions of the f1 helmet.  In the second version, the dome pad is a six-fingered star, which increased both comfort and ventilation.


Sliding buckles allow for a good fit on all straps.



Sponge-rubber or neoprene spacers provide indentation protection for the head of the wearer; there is a lot of resiliance in the suspension of this helmet.


Those familiar with the US M1 helmet will recognize these "A" washers.  Connected by a screw and nut which pass through the shell, they help secure the suspension to the shell.  The screw and nut combination characterizes the earlier of two versions of the f1.


Velcro tapes secure the headband to the suspension.


The Chinstrap is of a three-point design, making this suitable for airborne troops.


Velcro allows for adjustment of the headband.  It is very easy to get a good fit with this helmet.



Removing the cover reveals United Nations livery.

Now for a few action shots of this effective, well-designed, handsome, and soldier-friendly helmet:





The m.78 f1 helmet closed out the 80-some-odd year history of the steel combat helmet.  How fitting that the nation which produced the first steel combat helmet would field the last as well.

See you next time with another cool helmet from the collection.


Sources:

"Rockymountainralph", F1 helmet, Youtube, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OoFiuVUzehs&t=1271s

Camopedia, United States, https://www.camopedia.org/index.php/USA

Revuelta, Joseba. Cascos Del SigloXX, https://www.cascoscoleccion.com/francia/francia.html







Monday, July 8, 2024

Peacekeepers: United Nations helmets

 


From left to right: Netherlands M1 clone liner, US-made Canadian M1, French f1.

See you next time with another cool helmet from the collection.

Peace,

Mannie

Germany (Nazi), Luftwaffe m.40 combat helmet,

Several years ago I took some photos of the helmets at our local (privately owned) museum.   The late owner had about twenty really nice helmets, five of which ended up in my collection.  This one he was hanging on to, but he generously let me photograph it in detail.  

Here is a link to the German m.42, raw-edge luft model,  that I posted back in 2015.

This is an m.40 German helmet, issued to the Luftwaffe.  The m.40 is characterized by a rolled-rim, a stamped ventilator, and corner-less steel chinstrap loops.  This is a particularly nice specimen, and a fine example to guide your collecting efforts.





It is an m.40 in superb condition.  And from this point on, it'll just be a walk-around comprised of photos.





The finish of this helmet is close to 100%.



The decal is in wonderful shape as it the entire helmet.  And the m.m40 stamped ventilator is shown to good effect.


The liner is in pretty good condition, with some flaking along the edge.


One of the few discrepencies is that the tip is missing from the chinstrap, which is unfortunate as that is where the manufacture's mark is...manufacturer of the chinstrap, that is.


A close-up of the leather flaking.  Despite the claims of many, there is no way to reverse this.





The chinstrap loops of the earlier m.35, were cast aluminum with square corners, in subsequent models, including this m.40, the loops are steel wire with rounded corners.


I think it speaks well of my collecting discipline that I didn't buy it myself;  I have a nice army m.40 as well as a Luftwaffe m.42...not to mention, there is only so much wallspace.


A very handsome helmet, indeed!

See you next time with another cool helmet from the collection.

Mannie

 

Wednesday, July 3, 2024

United States PASGT (kevlar) helmet - part III, a soldier interview



This is the third and final post on the PASGT (Kevlar) helmet.  To view part I, go here.  To view part II, go here.  These previous posts contain loads of additional photographs and information, plus another interview with a paratrooper who wore the PASGT while fighting on Grenada during Operation Urgent Fury.

A park ranger friend of mine, John Nicholas, wore the PASGT during Operation Desert Shield/Desert Storm (Sept 1990 - March 1991) and again in Iraq (March 2003 - March 2004).  John generously took a moment during his busiest time of year - battle anniversary at Gettysburg - to talk with me about the helmet.

-----

Interview

John, thank your for participating.  I have just a few questions regarding your experience with the PASGT helmet when you were deployed to Iraq in 2003.

- When were you in the US Army, and where were you stationed?

Fort Jackson SC - Little Creek Naval Amphibious Base, VA, - BCH,VA- Fort Dix NJ - Fort Stewart GA - Saudi Arabia - Fort Devens, MA - Fort Huachua, AZ - Camp Red Cloud, S. Korea - Fort Lee, VA - Fort Hood, TX - FOB Ironhorse, Tikrit, Iraq - Fort Hood, TX - Fort Lee, VA - Fort Living Room.



- When you were in, did you see any of the older M1 helmet still in use?

Yes, that was the issue item at the time.  I think they started phasing them out around 1986 or '87




- What were your general feelings regarding the level of protection afforded to you by the PASGT helmet?

I thought it was better than the M1.  It protected the sides and back of the head and neck better.


- How comfortable was the PASGT, and what could you do to make it more so?

Well, if you never wear a helmet and then have to wear one all the time, it is a little uncomfortable at first, but you quickly get used to it after a couple of days or a week.  The webbing sitting directly on the head was uncomfortable.  Most put a foam "doughnut" in  the helmet directly on top of the webbing to make it comfortable.



- The M1 helmet, with its two-piece construction - shell and liner - made it an effective sink, shovel, cooking pot, footbath, etc.  Where there any alternatives uses for the PASGT?  If so, what in particular?

There was no liner for the helmet, because the kevlar helmet was thicker than the steel pot, you could not use it for anything other than what it was intended for.



- How was the PASGT accepted by the troops, especially those who had worn the M1 in their earlier career?

I never heard any complaints.


- What did you find to be the shortcomings of the helmet?

Because it was heaver, you could not really hang it on to anything.



- What kind of maintenance did the helmet require?

None.


- Did you wear the six-color "chocolate chip" cover, or did you use the later subdued three-color pattern?

The standard helmet cover was the "woodland" camouflage pattern.  The "chocolate chip desert" pattern came out around 1988 and was only a supplemental issue for units doing a rotation through the National Training Center at Fort Irwin, CA and then later for Operation Desert Shield/Desert Storm.  The new "desert" camouflage pattern came out around 1998.


- Do you still have your helmet, or did you have to turn it in?

You had to turn it in.


- Are there any final thoughts that you'd like to share?

Sometime before the run-up to the War in Iraq, the Army came out with new body armor, which I guess Natick Labs never actually field-tested.  Before deploying in 2003, the division commander of 4ID [IV Infantry Division] wanted everybody to qualify on their weapon before deploying with the new body armor.  For a large majority of soldiers, if you were firing from the prone position, the new body armor pushed the front of the helmet over your firing eye...


even if you removed the Kevlar collar off of the body armor.  This was a major problem in OIF [Operation Iraqi Freedom) 1 and 2 because there was no workaround.  A new helmet had to be designed, manufactured, and issued in 2006.  I never wore the new helmet.

Thank you John.

----------

As we continue the walk-around, do know that in the two posts previous to this one, I have discussed the development, use, and other specifics of the helmet, with many, many photographs.  I've covered the helmet in detail already, accordingly, this post will provide some additional views of the third PASGT in my collection.

Please go here for the full exploration of the PASGT helmet.



Note that the chinstrap is desert tan, rather than the olive drab of the previous PASGT helmets that I've posted.








(Note the desert grime)



Screws and "A" washers secure the suspension to the shell.  These through-holes present potential failure-points for the ballistic value of the shell.  This is something that I have not seen discussed, so perhaps it provides less of a compromise than I think it might.


The ferrule of the washer and it's corresponding screw.


The nomenclature stamp indicates that this helmet was manufactured by Unicor on the 1985 contract.


The cover was made in or near the year 2000, coincidentally, the last year of the 20th century and the end-point of the scope of my collection.  That the dates of the helmet and the cover are fifteen-years apart, speaks to the durability and service-life of the helmet.


Velcro tapes secure the cover to the suspension.


The cover is particularly well-made.


As with every generation of US helmets since 1917, the surface is textured to provide non-reflectivity.


The chinstrap fits through slits in the cover.


The plus-sign indicates the center of the mold and the 86/87 denotes the range of years that this contract was produced.  You can see a tiny tick-mark to the left of the "87" that indicates the actual year of manufacture.


The logo of Unicor, the manufacturer, is embossed in the dome.


"M-3"  denotes the size of the helmet.  The PASGT helmet came in five sizes, from extra-small to extra-large.  With the entry of women into war zones, a smaller-sized helmet was necessary.  Far different from the one-size-fits-all of the M1 helmet.


The insignia of the III Infantry Division is on either side of the helmet cover.


Rank indicator is on the front of the cover, indicating that this particular helmet was worn by a staff sergeant.


A robust snap fastens the chinstrap.



The three-color desert pattern was found to be more effective than the six-color "chocolate chip" pattern of the early Desert Storm operation.  The pattern pictured here was introduced toward the end of Desert Storm .

Action shots?...absolutely!



These are Air Force personnel coordinating air support,  Note the range of communications equipment that can be used with the PASGT.











This photo is significant in that it shows the PASGT helmet and the next generation ACH helmet (middle) deployed simultaneously, as the PASGT was leaving service and the ACH was entering.  The at-a-glance giveaway between the two is the absence of a visor on the ACH (Advanced Combat Helmet).





It's funny, how when the first PASGT came into the collection, I thought it was an ugly duckling, but over the years, it has become one of my favorites, and I am very happy to have them in the collection.

Special thanks to sergeant John for taking the time to participate. 


As you can see, John is still serving his country, but now as a Park Ranger for the National Park Service.  Here, John and I are are participating in the 150th anniversary of the Civil War at Antietam.  

Here is a post on my Park Ranger blog with views of the 150th events at Gettysburg the following year: https://volunteersinparks.blogspot.com/2013/07/gettysburg-150-july-3.html

I hope that you've enjoyed this multi-installment look at the US PASGT helmet.  Stop by again for a look at another cool helmet from the collection.

Mannie

Sources

Brayley, Martin J., Tin Hats to Composite Helmets: a collectors guide. The Crowood Press, 2008.

Yonggiang, Li, Science Direct vol 238, June 1, 2022,  Ballistic helmets: Recent advances in materials, protection mechanisms, performance, and head injury mitigation.  https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1359836822002694#preview-section-references


Digital Commonwealth, Massachusetts Collections Online, PASGT helmet development, https://www.digitalcommonwealth.org/search?page=8&q=PASGT+helmet+development&search_field=all_fields

Reynosa, Mark A., (PASGT) Helmet: an Illustrated Study of the U.S. Military's Current Issue Helmet.  Schiffer Military History, 1999.

Reynosa, Mark A., U.S.Combat Helmets of the 20th Century.  Schiffer Military History Books, 1997.

Army Navy Warehouse, Using Contract Numbers to Determine Dates on Military Gear, July 7, 2020.  https://www.armynavywarehouse.com/post/contract-number-dating

Camopedia, United States, https://www.camopedia.org/index.php/USA